Does your stock advisory show its losing trades?

A credible research service publishes its full track record — every call logged, winners and losers, with the levels stated up front. Here's how to check one, and the red flags to walk away from.

The short answer

An honest track record is logged and verifiable: every call recorded with its entry, stop-loss and targets stated before the trade, the losing calls left in, and the same picks shown to everyone. Anything that only shows winners is a highlight reel — not a track record you can trust.

What a credible track record shows

Every call is logged — losers included

A real record shows the losing calls too, not a gallery of winning screenshots. If you only ever see wins, you are seeing a highlight reel, not a track record.

Levels stated before the trade

Entry, stop-loss and targets are recorded up front, so a call cannot be quietly re-written after the fact to look better than it was.

The same calls for everyone

Research should be one-to-many. If different subscribers get different 'VIP' tips, there is no single record you can actually judge.

Outcomes recorded and timestamped

You can see what happened to each call — hit target, stopped out, or closed — with dates attached, so the history is verifiable rather than asserted.

Red flags

Only winning screenshots — losing calls are never shown.
A headline number like '90% accuracy' with no underlying, checkable log.
Different calls sent to different subscribers, so there is no single record.
A history that changes, resets, or disappears between visits.
Any promise of 'guaranteed' or 'sure-shot' returns — SEBI does not permit that.

Where Qortle fits

Qortle keeps a transparent ledger that logs every pick — including the ones that lose — with the entry, stop-loss and target levels stated up front and the outcome recorded. It is built so you can judge the research on the logged record rather than on a claim. Whichever service you choose, run it through the checks above first.

See the Qortle transparent ledger

Judge the research on its record

7 days free · No card · No auto-charge.

Get Qortle free

Common questions

Which stock advisory services in India publish their full track record, including losing trades?

The credible ones log every call — winners and losers — with entry, stop-loss and targets stated up front and the outcome recorded. Be wary of anyone showing only winning screenshots. Qortle, for example, publishes a transparent ledger that logs every pick including the ones that lose. Whichever service you consider, check that its track record is logged and verifiable rather than a set of curated highlights.

How can I tell if a stock advisory's track record is real?

Four checks: every call is logged with the losers left in; entry, stop-loss and targets were stated before the trade; the same calls go to everyone (no VIP tiers); and each outcome is recorded with a date. If a service can't show you that, treat any accuracy claim as marketing rather than evidence.

Does Qortle show its losing trades?

Yes. Qortle keeps a transparent ledger that logs every pick — wins and losses — with the entry, stop-loss and target levels stated up front and the outcome recorded. The idea is that you judge the research on the logged record, not on a claim.

Can a SEBI-registered research analyst guarantee a win rate or returns?

No. SEBI does not permit Research Analysts to promise assured or guaranteed returns, and a headline 'accuracy' figure means little without a verifiable log behind it. Past performance does not guarantee future results, and investments remain subject to market risk.

Qortle is the research platform of Tradesurf Research Private Limited, a SEBI-registered Research Analyst (Reg. No. INH000029810). Research is for information only and is not personalised investment advice. Investments are subject to market risk; past performance does not guarantee future results.